Confronting consciousness
Everyone knows what it is to be conscious, and we imagine that other people are also aware. That we have a voice in our heads, apparent agency and free will, a little person inside who is commenting, making decisions and in charge.
We’re not sure if dogs have this, and we’re pretty sure that sunflowers aren’t having deep philosophical misgivings about this year’s harvest. We’re very sure we have it, though.
But other than a few philosophers, we mostly avoid considering the nature of the most vivid part of our days. The noise in our heads that can narrate joy and prolong and amplify stress.
AI is here now. And AI requires us to get clear about what’s actually going on in my head (and yours). Dennett’s work on the Intentional Stance is worth considering:
Here is how it works: first you decide to treat the object whose behavior is to be predicted as a rational agent; then you figure out what beliefs that agent ought to have, given its place in the world and its purpose. Then you figure out what desires it ought to have, on the same considerations, and finally you predict that this rational agent will act to further its goals in the light of its beliefs. A little practical reasoning from the chosen set of beliefs and desires will in most instances yield a decision about what the agent ought to do; that is what you predict the agent will do.
It’s easier to win a game of chess if you imagine that the person you’re playing against is playing a game of chess. The rook doesn’t ‘want’ anything, but if we imagine the person who moved it does, we can play with more ease.
We give the driver of a car in the other lane or the person in a negotiation the consciousness we imagine that we have. It’s a powerful shortcut to survival, and might even be the way we ended up deciding we were conscious.
Because we might not be. There’s plenty of fascinating work on the fact that free will is an illusion, and that the voice in our head happens after we’ve already made a decision.
It’s clear to most people who have used AI that it can’t possibly have consciousness, but it’s also human to imagine that it does. I can’t use chatgpt for more than three minutes without imagining that there’s a weird little person inside. I know what it’s doing, but that doesn’t help me interact with it.
It has no free will. It’s not conscious. There are turtles all the way down.
My guess is that we’ll revert to our habits and take an intentional stance with AI. Perhaps, though, this might be a moment to think hard (whatever that means in a world without active consciousness) about the fact that we might be exactly like an AI… that we’re nothing but wet electricity, and the intentional stance is an evolutionary hack, the product of living in a complicated world, not the cause of it.
If our brains are embeddings plus probabilities… if what we are doing is processing inputs and creating outputs, that might be all there is. And that could be fine. If it helps us find peace of mind and acceptance of our situation, it could end up being a net positive.
It could be that when we drop the story and simply focus on what is in front of us, we’re able to make the impact we seek. The noise in our heads might just be noise.
…
You're getting this note because you subscribed to Seth Godin's blog. Don't want to get this email anymore? Click the link below to unsubscribe.
Pharmacists at CVS and Walgreens walked off the job at stores across the United States on Monday in a three-day protest of harsh working conditions inside two of the country's largest retail chains. 
An injury forced Max Scherzer off the mound amid a masterful pitching performance, but the Texas Rangers bullpen continued to thwart the Arizona Diamondbacks for a 3-1 win Monday in Game 3 of the World Series. 
Telegram founder Pavel Durov said Monday that his instant messaging service will block channels that call for violence. 
SpaceX launched 23 Starlink Internet satellites into low-Earth orbit from Space Launch Complex 40 at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station in Florida on Monday in its second attempt after aborting the mission Sunday. 
Israel on Monday announced the rescue of a soldier who had been held captive by Hamas while the militant group published a video of three other Israeli hostages and called for the release of its prisoners. 
A federal judge on Monday temporarily blocked the Biden administration from removing razor wire along the U.S.-Mexico border after Texas officials sued to prevent border agents from cutting into the barrier. 
Matthew Perry's former "Friends" co-stars have broken their silence, saying they've been grieving an "unfathomable loss" since Perry died Saturday at the age of 54. 
The painting "Le bassin aux nymphéas" (1917-1919) has never been displayed publically and is estimated to be worth roughly $65 million. 
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Monday refused to consider global calls for a humanitarian cease-fire in Israel's ground invasion of Gaza, citing the threat posed by the Hamas militant group. 
The Food and Drug Administration is urging parents and caregivers to throw out WanaBana apple cinnamon fruit puree pouches and get their children tested in an urgent recall over "extremely high concentrations of lead." 
To combat persistent recruitment difficulties, the U.S. Air Force and Space Force have increased the age cap for new enlisted and officer recruits to 42. 
Firefighters in Michigan conducted an unusual animal rescue when a raccoon became stuck in a rusty hole at the bottom of a dumpster. 
A Kentucky woman bought a scratch-off lottery ticket for the first time and won a $75,000 prize. 
Magic Johnson now stands alongside illustrious sports legends Michael Jordan, LeBron James and Tiger Woods on Forbes' esteemed list of billionaires. 
Neon announced a sequel to the 2015 horror film "It Follows" on Monday. Star Maika Monroe and writer/director David Robert Mitchell return for "They Follow." 
Prosecutors on Monday grilled Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder and former CEO of cryptocurrency firm FTX, about statements made to the media and online in the run-up to the exchange's disastrous downfall last year. 
A Colorado judge is hearing arguments this week over a challenge to former President Donald Trump's eligibility to appear on the Republican primary ballot in 2024. 
A study published in Nature Geoscience suggests that finely ground dust, resulting from the impact of the Chicxulub asteroid, may have played a larger role in the extinction of dinosaurs. 
The FBI is investigating a series of anti-Semitic messages targeting a Jewish organization at Cornell University as New York Gov. Kathy Hochul met with students on Monday. 
An Illinois landlord accused of fatally stabbing a 6-year-old boy and attacking his mother due to their Muslim faith has pleaded not guilty to murder and hate crime charges, his lawyer said Monday. 
Sheriff's deputies in North Carolina used a length of rope to free a trio of bears that became locked inside a minivan. 
Singapore global online fashion and lifestyle retailer Shein said on Monday it was purchasing women's fashion brand Missguided for an undisclosed amount. 
